SSL956 {L_WROTE}:
I dont understand why again in the above article YLF is pushing the emergency access angle. Surely it doesnt make a difference for a patient if they are able to get to the pier in much less time (30 seconds is a joke) if they then have to travel on the ferry for 25 minutes and then be transported from the Central pier to a hospital!!! For any cases where a few minutes difference is going to make a difference to the patient surely they would be airlifted. So her argument is completely redundant.
That was the excuse when it was first proposed, over 10 years ago. And of course since then they've built the helipad adjacent to the clinic.
And the ambulance station isn't at the clinic anyway. So WTF?
It's going to take the ambulance 10 minutes to get to the clinic from their station on a Sunday.
If you want to reduce response time for ambulance and fire to Main Street and the pier (for whatever reason) they should make a trafficable link from the fire station down through Yung Shue Long and straight to the middle of Main Street. That wouldn't take 30 seconds, but it would shave a few minutes and that path has very low traffic. They could put a gate at the top to keep VVs off it if necessary.
Currently there is a stairway on that path. For no logical reason, instead of doing that fairly simple bit of roadworks on a short section of the path, they preferred to make it go the long way, using it as an excuse to build up the detour, including the $55 million reclamation.
Of course, since we don't have a doctor at the clinic on Sunday, it's all pretty pointless.
What would it cost to have 24-hour doctor on Lamma? Maybe $500,000 a year? The reclamation could cover that for a century. People have died for lack of prompt medical care here, (David Slough) and in a typhoon, a high risk time for accidents, they couldn't use the helipad at all.
Let's just hope all our typhoons are during office hours when we have a doctor on hand. (Though when a #8 is called and the clinic is closed I expect the doctor catches the next ferry home to HK.)